There
is no shadow of a doubt on the fact that on the one hand, medical scientists have
achieved outstanding success in extending human life. On the other hand,
nowadays people hear more information about euthanasia and physician-assisted
suicide than ever before. Whether mercy killing should be legalized has
fostered a controversy amongst different people. In the following essay I want to
describe a reading passage published in USA Today Magazine in March 2000.
In
the editorial titled: “Death with Dignity: Choices and Challenges,” the author Girsh
F., the advocate of euthanasia, argue for the legalization of
physician-assisted suicide. He asserts that in the case of terminally ill
patients, it is crucial to allow people to have legal choice for death without
pain and suffering. Based upon the foregoing article, today, such medical innovations
as artificial organ, transplant, feeding tube and respirator actually prolong
the dying of terminally ill persons. As a result, many care places have been
built for them. For instance, the number of hospices for this category of
patients in the U.S. increased from one in 1974 to roughly 3000 in 2000. In
addition, to support his position, the aforementioned author refers to a number
of recent researches. According to these studies, growing rates of incurable
patients wish to have the legal possibility to die fast in order to prevent
their family members and themselves to suffer from their being in an
excruciating dying condition; for example, 56 % of persons with such cureless disease
as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis stated they would favor making identical
decision as a woman with the same disease did when she died with doctor
Kevorkian’s help, and 65 % of 30,000 Americans 55 years old and older who were
interviewed in a survey supported the proposition that patients with fatal
diseases should have the right for the lawful employment of a physician’s help
in case of death. Moreover, as shown by the statistics of Oregon, the only U.S.
state which has legalized physician-assisted dying, these were not any abuses
predicted by the opponents of the practice in question. For instance, during
the first year, six people from twenty three patients who have received medication
did not use it and died naturally. Finally, Girsh demonstrates that incurable
patients surveyed in a Canadian study determined such end-of-life significance
as evading stretched dying, reaching of managing feeling and alleviating the weight
on family members. In addition, he analyzes a case of 82 year-old Rose with
cureless pancreatic cancer. Because she is feeble, weary and bitterly aware of
her imminent death, she pleads for a fast and quiet death. However, neither her
doctor nor her children could help to deter her pains because euthanasia is an illegal
act
The
reading passage directly indicates that the high interest in physician-assisted
suicide really exists among incurable patients. Therefore, in my view, a
democratic government cannot fairly ignore the justifiable plea of such patient
to want to die peacefully. If a government declares that it respects the right
of choice of individuals, it should give the same legal opportunities for
people to decide how to live and how to die.
http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/2860481/death-dignity-choices-challenges 
No comments:
Post a Comment